I sometimes say that among the various skills and abilities one might gain from sincere training in Karate-Do, perhaps the most long-lasting gift is developing a “karate eye” when watching another karate practitioner perform.  After all, watching ice skating competition over the years, I can basically tell when a skater is doing well (or poorly) even though I cannot skate myself.  In the same way, you are developing an eye for karate thanks to your training.  While senior students may be able to identify the practitioner’s style after just a few moves, even those with just several years under their belt can see and appreciate good technique.

A while back, I came across a video showing a karate group during an examination.  Unfortunately, I was unable to identify the style, though it appeared to be Japanese.  I was especially intrigued by the group kata performance at the end (fast forward to 2 mins 30 secs) as it was not a kata that I’m familiar with.  I’m not sure if they always practice the kata at the speed or not.  The addition of background music by whomever edited the video did add a humorous flavor to the kata.  Each of you will likely view the performance using the “karate eye” that you have developed from your years of training.

Of course, each of us tends to evaluate and judge a karateka through the lense of our own personal experience. However, I do believe that these karateka were diligent and serious in their performance and displaying what they had learned.  Importantly, they appear to be very respectful each other and to their art.

Meanwhile, here’s a nine-year old black belt in Japan performing Heian Nidan – which every one of you is very familiar with.  Of course, you’ll likely view his performance using your “karate eye” which has been developed practicing the same Shotokan style as his.

Hmmm….I wonder what we look like when viewed through the “karate eye” of a practitioner from another dojo or style?